Strategy
Pioneers, settlers, town planners: three attitudes for three stages of evolution
Simon Wardley's model of three attitudes, pioneers, settlers and town planners, each suited to a different stage of evolution on a map.
Pioneers, settlers and town planners (PST) is Simon Wardley's model of three attitudes in an organisation, each suited to a different stage of evolution: pioneers explore the new, settlers turn it into products, and town planners industrialise it.
The idea builds on Robert Cringely's "commandos, infantry, police" from Accidental Empires. Wardley adapted it to fit the evolution stages on a map.
The three attitudes
Pioneers work in the uncharted, at genesis. They explore, invent and try things that may not work. Many of their experiments fail, and that is expected. Wardley points to agile methods as a good fit, because the work is uncertain and changes fast.
Settlers take the pioneers' prototypes and make them into products. They work where a component moves from custom-built to product. They listen to users, learn what the product needs and make it usable by many people, not just a few. Wardley points to lean methods here.
Town planners take the product and industrialise it into a commodity or utility service. They make it standard, efficient and reliable. Wardley points to approaches such as Six Sigma, which suit work that is well understood.
Each group needs different methods because the work is different. One method for all three is a poor fit. That is the same point as the "use appropriate methods" principle in doctrine.
The system of theft
Things only keep evolving if someone carries them to the next stage. In Wardley's account, each group takes over the work of the one before it. Settlers take what pioneers have built and turn it into products. Town planners take those products and industrialise them. The pioneers are then free to build new things on top of the industrialised parts.
Wardley calls this a system of theft. No group owns a component for good. The work moves on, and so do the people who suit it.
Attitude, not rank or talent
PST describes how people prefer to work, not how senior or skilled they are. A pioneer is not a better engineer than a town planner. All three are equally valuable, and an organisation that wants to cope with change needs all three. This links to the doctrine principle "think aptitude and attitude".
How it differs from dual structures
Dual structures, often called bimodal, split an organisation into two: one part to explore, one part to run things. Wardley argues in the book that this is flawed, because it ignores the middle. Without settlers, the pioneers' work never evolves, and the two sides tend to fight. See the passage on dual structures.
Using it with a map
- Draw the map and place each component by its stage of evolution.
- Look at which stage each component sits in.
- Ask which attitude that component needs: pioneers for genesis, settlers for custom-built to product, town planners for product to commodity.
- Compare this with who owns the component today.
Components move to the right over time, so the answer changes. Revisit it as the map changes.
Common mistakes
- Treating the three as job titles or levels in a hierarchy.
- Giving every component to one kind of team, then wondering why it struggles.
- Splitting into only two groups and leaving out the settlers.
- Expecting pioneers to run a stable service, or town planners to invent something new.
- Letting a team hold on to a component after it has evolved. That is a form of inertia.
Working out which teams should own which parts of your landscape? The applied workshop works through it with your team.